I saw Pride & Prejudice on Thansgiving morning. And today I
finally caught up with the latest Harry Potter film. The connection
between the two is in the way they were both reviewed, by comparison
to other adaptations of the same works. In the case of P&P the
comparisons were to the A&E miniseries with Jennifer Ehle and
Colin Firth. The reviewers I read or heard seemed equally divided;
half preferred the longer TV version, half the new film. (Nobody
mentioned the Greer Garson/Laurence Olivier version, which isn't a
surprise if you ever tried to watch it.) Me, I'm torn. I like the
miniseries a lot; I've watched it on DVD at least a half dozen times.
I like the pace, the way they have enough time to tell a romantic
story in glances and smiles and the odd gulp. But the new movie has
its charms too, even if it does feel kind of rushed. For one thing,
it feels more
alive, as if these are real people and not just
literary creations spouting clever dialogue. And the surroundings are
much grittier; there's a lot more dung in the movie, and a lot more
clothing that looks like it would last, and rooms that look the way a
room would look when it's been lived in for a few decades. I guess in
the end I have to say I like them both, but wish each could have had
the benefits of the other. And I should also mention how strange it
felt to be one of a very few men in a theater filled with women.
Dunno why Jane Austen doesn't appeal to more men. Or maybe they just
aren't willing to go public on the subject.
Now for that connection I promised. Harry Potter & The Goblet of
Fire is the fourth film, with the third director. I'd heard both good
and less good things about Mike Newell, the director on GoF. Some
people thought he had less imagination than Alfonso Cuarón, the
director of Prisoner of Azkaban. Others felt like GoF worked in a way
the three previous films didn't. (Interestingly, nobody had much good
to say about Chris Columbus, who directed the first two films.
Workmanlike was about as kind as they were willing to get.)
Me, I liked GoF, and in ways I hadn't expected. Unlike the earlier
films, this one is exciting, layered and filled with moments of real
danger. It's more than a roller coaster ride, where you know the hero
will emerge at the other end but just don't know how. There's a real
feeling of fright and peril and uncertainty that was missing earlier
in the series. And (and here comes another connection) there's a
feeling of realism and grit to the look of the film that's new as
well. The Hogwarts of the earlier installments looked like a Disneyland
creation; this one has a worn and functional feel of a real school,
even if it has all kinds of magic about it. I can't wait for the next
volume, which is something I wouldn't have said up to this point.
Book five wasn't my favorite, but given the right director, the film
version may just surprise me.